Product Filter
West Virginia has a strong storytelling tradition. Nowhere is that more evident than our wide range of cryptids. You may know the Mothman but he's just the beginning. Grafton and Flatwoods have their monsters too, plus there's the Snarly Yow, the Grinning Man, Sheepsquatch, Bat Boy, and more. Whether you're looking for something whimsical (Flatwoods Monster and Mothman sharing a WV hotdog, anyone?) or would like to take a deeper dive into the myths, legends, and even anatomy of these mystical creatures, The Red Caboose is your home for all things cryptid.

244 products found in Monsters and Myths of West Virginia

Live Laugh Lurk Sticker
  • $3.50
Wild & Wonderful Cryptid Sticker
  • $3.50
Squatch Bar Soap
  • $10.00

Sold out

Live Laugh Lurk Magnet
  • $3.00
Live Laugh Lurk Patch
  • $6.00
Lurkin' for the Weekend Sticker
  • $3.50
Wild & Wonderful Cryptids Magnet
  • $3.50
Monsters & Ghosts of West Virginia
  • $9.95
Mothman Polaroid Sticker
  • $4.00
Holographic Mothman Live Laugh Lurk
  • $3.50
Cryptid Tandem Magnet
  • $3.00
Mothman Live Laugh Lurk Bumper Sticker
  • $5.00
Holographic Sasquatch Trailblazer Sticker
  • $3.50
Lamp Of My Life Mothman Mini Print
  • $2.50
Mothman and Moon Enamel Pin Set
  • $10.00
Mothman Night Flight Notecard
  • $3.50
Holographic Flying High Mothman Sticker
  • $3.50
Flatwoods Monster and UFO Enamel Pin Set
  • $10.00
Mothman Magnet
  • $5.00
Baby Mothman Ornament
  • $10.00
Cryptids of WV Map Art Print 11x17
  • $20.00
Mothman CREAM Sticker
  • $3.50
Night Moves Mothman T-Shirt
  • $30.00
Mothman on Top of Silver Bridge Notecard
  • $3.50
West Virginia's Dark Tourism
  • $24.99
Big Book of West Virginia Ghost Stories
  • $19.95
Mothman - WV Cryptid Art Print - 8 1/2 x 11
  • $20.00
Sasquatch Enamel Pin
  • $8.00
Cryptid Hot Dog Art Print 8x10
  • $10.00
Braxton Co Monster Notecard
  • $3.50
Map of West Virginia Cryptids Postcard/Mini Print
  • $2.50
Mushroom Fairy Sticker
  • $4.50
Baby Flatwoods Ornament
  • $10.00
A Guide to Haunted West Virginia
  • $19.95
The Telltale Lilac Bush
  • $19.95
Mothman in Barbed Wire Notecard
  • $3.50
Bestiary Mothman Sticker
  • $5.00
Flatwoods monster button
  • $2.50
I Want to Believe Ornament
  • $10.00
Yeti Greeting Card - 5 x 7
  • $6.00
Mothman Caught in Headlights Notecard
  • $3.50
Bigfoot Suncatcher/Ornament
  • $28.00
Mothman's Cryptid Cookie Box Postcard/Mini Print
  • $2.50
Strange West Virginia Monsters
  • $16.99
Eerie Appalachia
  • $21.99
Scary Mothman sticker
  • $4.00
App-Uh-Latch-uh Coloring Book
  • $22.00
Mothman Acrylic Pin
  • $8.00